Hidden Gems: Unique Things to Do in Martha’s Vineyard Beyond the Beaches

When people think of Martha’s Vineyard, they often imagine long stretches of pristine beaches, quaint harbor towns, and summer getaways.

However, if you’re looking to go beyond the typical tourist spots, this charming island is filled with hidden gems that only seasoned visitors and locals tend to explore.

From lesser-known historical sites to off-the-beaten-path adventures, here are some of the most unique things to do in Martha’s Vineyard that take you beyond the beaches.

Whether you’re visiting for the first time or the tenth, there’s always something new to discover on this enchanting island.

1. Explore Historical Landmarks with a Twist

Martha’s Vineyard is rich in history, but it’s not just about old lighthouses and ferry docks.

These lesser-known landmarks provide a glimpse into the island’s fascinating past:

Vincent House Museum: Located in Edgartown, this is the island’s oldest residence, built in 1672. Visiting the museum offers a unique chance to step back in time and experience how early settlers lived. It’s a quiet, intimate look at the Vineyard’s history—without the usual crowds.
The Old Whaling Church: While many visitors pass by this striking building, few stop to appreciate its significance. Originally built in 1843 for the town’s whaling community, it now serves as a cultural center hosting art shows, concerts, and local events. Be sure to check the schedule for an opportunity to attend an event during your visit.

2. Discover Secret Gardens and Hidden Parks

Beyond the well-trodden walking trails lies a serene side of Martha’s Vineyard, perfect for those seeking a peaceful escape:

Polly Hill Arboretum: This 70-acre botanical garden in West Tisbury is a quiet sanctuary far from the island’s busier attractions. Stroll through beautifully maintained gardens featuring unique plant species and hidden benches that offer the perfect spot to unwind and soak in nature.
Mytoi Gardens on Chappaquiddick Island: A hidden gem nestled within a pine forest, this Japanese-inspired garden is a serene retreat with winding paths, koi ponds, and elegant landscaping. It’s an often-overlooked spot that transports you to a tranquil world of calm, perfect for a reflective afternoon.

3. Off-the-Beaten-Path Activities

Martha’s Vineyard offers much more than sunbathing and sailing.

Try these unconventional activities for a day you won’t soon forget:

The FARM Institute: This working farm is not just a place to buy fresh produce; it’s a hands-on experience. Visitors can learn about sustainable farming practices, interact with farm animals, and even join workshops. Perfect for families and anyone interested in farm-to-table living.
Island Alpaca Company: Who would have thought you could visit alpacas on Martha’s Vineyard? This quirky farm offers an up-close-and-personal experience with alpacas, including farm tours, alpaca yoga, and a chance to browse their shop for unique alpaca wool items.

4. Culinary Experiences Off the Beaten Path

Dining on Martha’s Vineyard is more than just seafood shacks and upscale restaurants.

For a true local experience, venture into these hidden foodie spots:

7a Foods: Tucked away in West Tisbury, this deli and bakery is a local favorite known for its sandwiches and pastries made from scratch. The laid-back atmosphere and farm-fresh ingredients make it a great stop for breakfast or lunch before exploring the island.
Morning Glory Farm: This family-owned farm and market offer a wide range of fresh vegetables, fruits, baked goods, and prepared foods. For a true taste of the Vineyard’s bounty, grab some farm-fresh ingredients for a picnic or check out their bakery section for delicious, homemade pies.

5. Adventure Awaits on Secluded Trails and Waters

For outdoor enthusiasts looking to explore nature beyond the beaches, these hidden spots offer the perfect adventure:

Chappaquiddick Island’s Mytoi Gardens and Dike Bridge: For a combination of quiet nature and historical intrigue, explore the area around the Dike Bridge, infamous from the Chappaquiddick incident, and enjoy birdwatching or a peaceful kayak ride along the island’s shoreline.
Tisbury Great Pond: Skip the crowded harbors and opt for kayaking or paddleboarding on this quiet, scenic pond. With fewer tourists, it’s a peaceful way to enjoy the water and take in the beautiful surroundings.

6. Don’t Miss Quirky Local Events and Festivals

For a taste of the Vineyard’s local culture, check out some of the island’s unique festivals and pop-up events:

Martha’s Vineyard Film Festival: Held in various locations across the island, this film festival showcases independent films with an emphasis on social and environmental issues. It’s a great way to enjoy a cultural experience while mingling with locals and fellow travelers.
Artisan Fairs and Farmers’ Markets: If you’re visiting during the summer, be sure to stop by one of the local craft fairs or farmers’ markets. They’re an excellent opportunity to pick up handmade goods, chat with local artisans, and discover some of the island’s most talented creators.

7. Practical Tips for Exploring Hidden Gems

To make the most of your time on Martha’s Vineyard, here are a few practical tips for finding these off-the-beaten-path treasures:

Timing: Many of these hidden gems are less crowded in the morning or later in the afternoon, so plan your visits accordingly to avoid the midday rush.
Transportation: Some of these locations, like Chappaquiddick Island or Polly Hill Arboretum, are best explored with a car or bike. Public transportation is available, but having your own vehicle gives you more flexibility to explore at your own pace.
Ask Locals: Don’t hesitate to strike up a conversation with locals—they often know about hidden spots and can offer personal recommendations on what to see and do.

8. And Of Course, The Beaches

No trip to Martha’s Vineyard would be complete without mentioning its iconic beaches.

While this post focuses on hidden gems beyond the shoreline, the island’s beaches deserve a nod for their sheer beauty and variety.

Here are a few must-visit beaches that offer more than just sun and sand:

Menemsha Beach: Known for its spectacular sunsets, Menemsha is a quiet beach that feels like a hidden gem, especially in the late afternoon. Pack a picnic or grab some seafood from the nearby Menemsha Fish Market, and settle in for an unforgettable sunset view.
Lobsterville Beach: Tucked away on the less-traveled Aquinnah side of the island, Lobsterville Beach is a peaceful haven for fishing, swimming, and birdwatching. Its calm waters make it perfect for kayaking, and the quiet ambiance offers a serene escape from the busier beaches.
Lambert’s Cove Beach: Accessible only to residents and those staying in West Tisbury, Lambert’s Cove Beach is one of the island’s best-kept secrets. Its soft white sands and calm waters are perfect for families looking for a more secluded beach experience.

Even though these beaches are popular, their unique features and tranquil vibes make them feel like hidden gems in their own right.

Whether you’re lounging with a good book, wading in the water, or catching a famous Vineyard sunset, the island’s beaches are undeniably part of its charm.

What to Wear: Martha’s Vineyard Summer Outfits

Martha’s Vineyard is synonymous with timeless coastal charm, and its summer fashion reflects this blend of casual elegance and nautical influences. Whether exploring picturesque towns or relaxing by the beach, dressing for the island is all about comfort, practicality, and style. Here’s your guide to curating the perfect wardrobe for a Martha’s Vineyard summer getaway:

Daytime Attire

Light Dresses and Jumpsuits: Opt for breathable fabrics like linen or cotton in soft shades or understated patterns. These pieces offer ease and sophistication for wandering through towns like Edgartown or Oak Bluffs.
Classic Tops and Bottoms: Pair tailored shorts or white denim with breezy tops in stripes or floral prints. A lightweight cardigan or pullover is handy for cooler mornings and evenings.

Beachwear Essentials

Swimwear and Cover-ups: Go for timeless swimsuits like one-pieces or high-waisted bikinis in nautical hues. Layer with flowy cover-ups or tunics that easily transition from beach lounging to seaside dining.
Comfortable Footwear: Flip-flops are great for the beach, but consider espadrilles or slip-on sandals for a stylish touch when exploring boardwalks and shops.

Evening Elegance

Coastal Chic: For dinners or sunset gatherings, choose a maxi dress or tailored summer pants paired with a sophisticated blouse. Wedge sandals or ballet flats add a polished look.
Layer Up: Martha’s Vineyard evenings can be breezy, so pack a lightweight jacket or a soft shawl for extra warmth.

Must-Have Accessories

Hats and Sunglasses: A wide-brimmed straw hat and oversized sunglasses not only provide sun protection but also add a touch of glamour to your outfit.
Totes and Bags: A stylish tote bag is perfect for carrying essentials like sunscreen, a water bottle, and any treasures you pick up at local shops.

Footwear for All Occasions

Walking-Friendly Shoes: Cobblestone streets and unpaved paths call for practical yet stylish footwear. White sneakers, loafers, or flat sandals are great options for day trips.

Style Tips for the Vineyard

Layer Smartly: Weather on the island can change quickly, so always have a light sweater or jacket on hand.
Stay True to the Aesthetic: Embrace Martha’s Vineyard’s signature style by incorporating preppy elements like pastel colors, nautical stripes, and boat shoes into your outfits.

By focusing on effortless elegance and versatility, you’ll not only look the part but feel at home in the easygoing yet refined atmosphere of Martha’s Vineyard. Whether you’re hitting the beach, strolling through town, or enjoying a romantic dinner, this guide will ensure you’re perfectly dressed for every moment.

Martha’s Vineyard is much more than just its famous beaches.

From serene gardens and historical landmarks to off-the-beaten-path activities, unique culinary experiences, and local festivals, this island is filled with hidden treasures waiting to be discovered.

But, of course, don’t forget to indulge in the natural beauty of the beaches while you explore the less-traveled corners of the island.

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned traveler, Martha’s Vineyard always has something new to offer.

What hidden gem or beach will you explore on your next trip?

Where to Stay: Unique Accommodations in Martha’s Vineyard

After a day spent discovering hidden gems and exploring beyond the beaches, you’ll need a place to relax and recharge.

Martha’s Vineyard offers a wide range of accommodation options, from cozy inns to luxurious hotels, many of which capture the island’s unique charm.

Here are a few standout places to stay:

The Christopher: Located in the heart of Edgartown, this boutique hotel offers a blend of historic charm and modern amenities. With vibrant decor and cozy spaces, The Christopher is perfect for travelers looking for a stylish yet intimate place to stay. Its central location means you’re just steps away from restaurants, shops, and ferry access.

Book on Expedia

The Beach Plum Inn: For those seeking a quiet, secluded retreat, The Beach Plum Inn in Menemsha offers stunning views of the Vineyard Sound and quaint cottages tucked into nature. With its rustic charm and peaceful setting, it’s ideal for couples looking for a romantic escape.

The Nobnocket Boutique Inn: Situated in Vineyard Haven, this modern, award-winning inn combines contemporary design with top-notch service. Guests love its sleek decor, artful interiors, and proximity to Vineyard Haven’s harbor and ferry. The Nobnocket is perfect for travelers who appreciate modern luxury and attention to detail.

Lambert’s Cove Inn: Located near the famous Lambert’s Cove Beach, this charming inn offers a peaceful, countryside experience. With lush gardens, a seasonal pool, and private access to one of the island’s best beaches, it’s a great choice for families and nature lovers who want to enjoy the quieter side of the Vineyard.

The Hob Knob: A classic Martha’s Vineyard experience awaits at The Hob Knob, a luxury eco-boutique hotel in Edgartown. This beautifully restored 19th-century property features charming rooms, organic breakfast options, and even a wellness spa. It’s perfect for visitors who want a high-end, eco-conscious stay close to the island’s main attractions.

Tips for Choosing Where to Stay

Location: If you want easy access to shops, restaurants, and nightlife, stay in Edgartown or Vineyard Haven. For a quieter, more remote experience, Menemsha or West Tisbury offer peaceful accommodations with natural surroundings.
Transportation: Consider whether you’ll have a car or plan to use bikes or public transport. Staying in more central areas like Oak Bluffs or Edgartown makes getting around easier without a vehicle.
Book Early: Martha’s Vineyard is a popular destination, especially in the summer months, so be sure to book your accommodations well in advance.

Martha’s Vineyard is a treasure trove of hidden gems, from serene gardens and off-the-beaten-path activities to charming accommodations that enhance your island experience.

Whether you’re exploring beyond the beaches or unwinding at a cozy inn, the island offers something for every traveler.

Pair your adventure with a unique place to stay, and you’ll discover that things to do in Martha’s Vineyard go far beyond the expected.

Which hidden spot and accommodation will you try on your next visit?

Conclusion

Martha’s Vineyard may be known for its stunning beaches, but as you’ve seen, there’s so much more to this island than meets the eye.

From secret gardens to historical landmarks, off-the-beaten-path culinary delights, and unique local events, the hidden gems of Martha’s Vineyard offer something for every kind of traveler.

So next time you visit, venture beyond the beaches and discover the island’s lesser-known treasures.

What unique things will you find on your next trip to Martha’s Vineyard?

By following this guide, you’ll unlock a side of the Vineyard few tourists ever see.

Be sure to explore these hidden gems, and let us know your favorite spots in the comments below!

FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions About Things to Do in Martha’s Vineyard

To help make your visit to Martha’s Vineyard as smooth and enjoyable as possible, we’ve compiled a detailed FAQ section to answer some common questions about exploring the island.

Q1: What are the best non-beach activities on Martha’s Vineyard?

Martha’s Vineyard offers a variety of unique activities beyond its beaches, including:

Visiting Polly Hill Arboretum and Mytoi Gardens for peaceful nature walks.
Touring historical sites like the Vincent House Museum and The Old Whaling Church.
Engaging with the local farming scene at The FARM Institute and Island Alpaca Company.
Exploring local art at galleries like Louisa Gould Gallery or attending the Martha’s Vineyard Film Festival for cultural enrichment.

Q2: What is the best time of year to visit Martha’s Vineyard?

The best time to visit depends on your preferences:

Summer (June-August): The peak tourist season with warm weather, beach activities, and festivals. It’s also the most crowded and expensive time.
Spring (April-May): Ideal for quieter visits, cooler weather, and blooming gardens. The island is less crowded, making it easier to explore hidden gems.
Fall (September-October): A wonderful time for those who want fewer crowds and milder weather. The fall foliage is stunning, and activities like apple picking are popular.
Winter (November-March): If you’re looking for solitude, this is the time to visit. Some attractions close for the season, but the peaceful atmosphere is perfect for a quiet retreat.

Q3: What are the best hidden spots on Martha’s Vineyard for outdoor activities?

For those seeking outdoor adventures away from the crowds, some of the best hidden spots include:

Tisbury Great Pond for kayaking or paddleboarding in calm, scenic waters.
Chappaquiddick Island for secluded hiking, birdwatching, and exploring the quiet shores.
Menemsha Hills Reservation for scenic hikes with panoramic views of the Vineyard Sound.
Lobsterville Beach for fishing, swimming, and birdwatching without the large crowds found at other beaches.

Q4: Is Martha’s Vineyard family-friendly?

Absolutely! Martha’s Vineyard is an excellent destination for families, offering:

Kid-friendly beaches like Owen Park Beach and Joseph Sylvia State Beach, where the waters are calm and safe for children.
Family activities like visiting Island Alpaca Company, where kids can interact with animals, or taking a farm tour at The FARM Institute.
Plenty of outdoor adventures such as bike rentals, lighthouse tours, and exploring Felix Neck Wildlife Sanctuary, which offers educational programs and nature walks suitable for all ages.

Q5: How do I get around Martha’s Vineyard?

There are several ways to get around the island:

By Car: Having a car allows you to explore remote areas like Chappaquiddick Island and Menemsha. Keep in mind that ferry reservations for cars can fill up quickly in the summer.
Public Transportation: The island’s bus system, run by the Vineyard Transit Authority (VTA), connects most towns and major attractions. It’s affordable and convenient for those without a car.
Biking: Martha’s Vineyard is very bike-friendly, with plenty of rental shops and bike paths. It’s a great way to explore the island at your own pace, especially in the quieter areas.
Taxis & Ride-Sharing: Taxis are available, but they can be more expensive. Ride-sharing options are limited, so plan ahead if you’re relying on this for transportation.

Q6: What are some great local dining spots off the beaten path?

For unique local dining experiences, try:

7a Foods: A hidden gem in West Tisbury, known for its fresh sandwiches and baked goods.
Morning Glory Farm: A farm-to-table market offering fresh produce, bakery items, and ready-to-eat meals. It’s perfect for grabbing a picnic lunch.
The Red Cat Kitchen: Located in Oak Bluffs, this restaurant is a favorite for foodies looking for creative, farm-fresh meals with an intimate vibe.
Back Door Donuts: An iconic late-night spot where you can grab freshly made donuts from the back door of a bakery after hours.

Q7: Do I need to make reservations in advance for activities or restaurants?

For Restaurants: During the summer season, it’s highly recommended to make reservations, especially for popular spots in Edgartown and Oak Bluffs. Many smaller restaurants may not take reservations, so be prepared for a wait.
For Activities: Booking ferry tickets, especially if you’re bringing a car, should be done well in advance during peak season. For some activities like farm tours at Island Alpaca Company or kayaking excursions, advance bookings are also recommended, particularly in summer.

Q8: What are some must-see places for art and culture on Martha’s Vineyard?

If you’re a fan of art and culture, be sure to visit:

Martha’s Vineyard Film Center: Offering independent films and documentaries year-round, it’s a cultural hub for movie lovers.
The Granary Gallery: One of the island’s most renowned art galleries featuring works from local and international artists.
Louisa Gould Gallery: A hidden gem in Vineyard Haven, showcasing maritime-inspired artwork and local photography.

Q9: How do I find the best views on the island?

For the best panoramic views of Martha’s Vineyard, head to:

Aquinnah Cliffs: These majestic clay cliffs offer one of the most spectacular views on the island, especially at sunset.
Menemsha Hills: The scenic hike here leads to breathtaking views over the Vineyard Sound, with a vantage point that stretches all the way to the Elizabeth Islands.
East Chop Lighthouse: Climb to the top of this iconic lighthouse for sweeping views of Vineyard Haven Harbor and beyond.

Q10: What is the best way to experience Martha’s Vineyard in one weekend?

To make the most of a weekend on Martha’s Vineyard:

Day 1: Spend the day exploring Edgartown, visiting the historical Vincent House Museum, and enjoying a leisurely lunch at 7a Foods. In the evening, head to Menemsha Beach for an unforgettable sunset.
Day 2: Visit Polly Hill Arboretum or Mytoi Gardens for a quiet morning of nature walks, then head to Chappaquiddick Island for some outdoor adventure. Finish the day with a fresh farm-to-table dinner at Morning Glory Farm.
Day 3: Explore the quieter side of the island with a visit to Lobsterville Beach or paddleboarding on Tisbury Great Pond. Don’t forget to grab some goodies from Back Door Donuts on your way out!

From unique hidden gems to must-see landmarks and top-notch dining spots, Martha’s Vineyard offers a rich variety of activities and experiences beyond its famous beaches.

With this comprehensive guide, including FAQs, practical tips, and insider knowledge, you’ll be well-prepared to explore the island like a local.

Whether you’re staying for a weekend or longer, the things to do in Martha’s Vineyard go far beyond the ordinary, ensuring you leave with unforgettable memories and new discoveries.

What hidden gem will you explore on your next visit?

The FAQ section provides practical, detailed answers to common visitor questions, enhancing the post’s usefulness and making it more likely to convert readers into action by helping them plan their trip with confidence.

Top 10 Must-See Places to Visit in Colorado This Year

Plan Your Trip: The Best Time to Visit Yellowstone for Every Type of Traveler